by Higgenbotham » Sat Nov 21, 2026 3:09 pm
Looking at long term growth rates over the past 2000 years, population has grown 30 fold and wealth 600 fold, according to AI's best estimate of wealth now and 2000 years ago. This would put the average growth rate of wealth over the past 2000 years at 0.3 percent per year.
What did one of the Market Wizards say about a penny at the the time of Christ?
In Jack D. Schwager’s Market Wizards, trader Ed Seykota suggested computing the value of one penny invested at the time of Christ and compounded at 3% per year, then considering why nobody has anywhere near that amount today. [1, 2]
Key Points from Seykota's Thought Experiment
The Compounding Paradox: Over roughly 2,026 years, a single cent ($0.01) compounded annually at 3% grows to approximately $1.02 × 10²⁴ (over a septillion dollars).
Why Nobody Has It: In real-world history, uninterrupted compounding at that scale does not happen because wars, collapses, confiscation, and currency debasement interrupt wealth preservation. [1]
Gold and Debasement: Seykota noted that inflation sweeps away old orders, currencies get debased, and gold gets dug up, refined, and buried again—trending toward centralized vaults rather than endless individual compounding. [1]
You can read more about his profile and quotes on 7 Circles or view a copy of Market Wizards via ValuePlays.
What is your long-term outlook for inflation, the dollar, and gold?
Inflation is part of the way societies sweep away the old order. All currencies eventually get debased—like it
or not. Compute one penny invested at the time of Christ, compounded at 3 percent per year. Then consider why nobody has anywhere near that amount these days.
Gold tends to be dug up, refined, and then buried again. The geographical entropy of all gold on the planet
seems to decrease over time. A lot has been collected in vaults. I project the trend as one toward a central world gold stash.
Interview with Ed Seykota in
THE MARKET WIZARDS
CONVERSATIONS WITH AMERICA'S TOP TRADERS
JACK D. SCHWAGER
What was your worst year? What went wrong?
One of my worst years was 1980. The bull markets had ended, but I kept trying to hold on and buy back in at
lower prices. The markets just kept on breaking. I had never seen a major bear market before, so I was all set up for an important educational experience.
Higgenbotham wrote: Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:44 pm
Higgenbotham wrote: Fri Nov 06, 2026 2:36 pm
There will be a new set of winners who can be identified later. Kind of like how Joe Granville was the man in the 1970s.
I don't think the world any longer correctly understands Joe Granville. This article perhaps comes the closest but it's still off the mark.
What Happened: On this day in 1981, Joe Granville warned his newsletter readers to "Sell everything!"
Where The Market Was: The Dow closed at 1,004.69 and the S&P 500 traded at 138.12.
Granville's Bold Prediction: On Jan. 6, 1981, in his weekly newsletter, Granville warned investors that a stock market crash was on the horizon and they should dump all their stocks. The following day, the Dow tanked 4.2% on record trading volume of 92.9 million shares, making Granville look like a genius.
A year after Granville's call, the Dow was still down 14%, and Granville had become famous for calling the drop. At the time, Granville has 11,000 newsletter subscribers paying $250 per year for his insight. Others paid $500 for urgent phone alerts.
Granville's followers praised him for his 1981 call, his prediction of the bear market in the late 1970s and his bearish call ahead of the bursting of the dot-com bubble in 2000. Critics point out that he completely missed the bull market that started in 1982.
While Granville gained notoriety for his 1981 call, his overall performance was far from impressive. From 1980 through January 2005, Granville's stock picks for investors lost 0.5% on an annualized basis compared to an 11.9% average yearly gain from the market as a whole.
https://finance.yahoo.com/news/day-mark ... 00153.html
As other articles incorrectly state, Joe Granville was not primarily a showman. Granville had a good understanding of markets. He was primarily a bearish stock market prognosticator who made a number of correct stock market calls as the bear market wound its way down to the 1982 low. As posted awhile back, the Buffett Indicator made its low of 0.32 in 1982. That's how he got his following of tens of thousands of subscribers, not because of his showmanship.
For the purposes of what is being discussed here, it doesn't matter that Joe Granville missed the bull market post 1982 and lost his subscribers money after 1982. As long as there is no bull market coming for the next 20 years.
Whoever that person is (or persons are, hopefully) who is now bearish and can reasonably find the twists and turns to the bottom of the coming bear market is yet to be identified. Granville had a great run in the 70s, calling a number of turns. That seems to have been completely forgotten. That's why he was seemingly able to move markets.
If a bear market is starting someone with a similar talent will probably come to the fore. I will be on the lookout for such a person and will take their opinion into account. But as of yet there is no such identifiable person.
I read the Seykota interview 32 years ago. It's much more meaningful today, particularly given the environment that I believe we are going into. Reading the entire Seykota interview in Market Wizards will give good insight into what I'm talking about here. For one:
What is the most important advice you can give the average trader?
That he should find a superior trader to do his trading for him, and then go find something he really loves to
do.
One thing to keep in mind is that Seykota built and used a trend following system at the time the US entered the maintenance phase of a declining civilization. His success appears to have been temporarily interrupted just at the time when Joe Granville was in his heyday.
From the Seykota interview:
What was your first trading-related job?
I landed my first job on Wall Street in the early 1970s..
What is the performance track record?
I do not publicize my track record other than my "model account," which is an actual customer account that
started with $5,000 in 1972 and has made over $15 million.
This is similar to how Warren Buffet got established at the time the last crisis ended and the US entered into a big growth phase and world domination, which was the perfect environment for his talent. I believe that if Buffet were coming of age today, he would die penniless.
Looking at long term growth rates over the past 2000 years, population has grown 30 fold and wealth 600 fold, according to AI's best estimate of wealth now and 2000 years ago. This would put the average growth rate of wealth over the past 2000 years at 0.3 percent per year.
What did one of the Market Wizards say about a penny at the the time of Christ?
In Jack D. Schwager’s Market Wizards, trader Ed Seykota suggested computing the value of one penny invested at the time of Christ and compounded at 3% per year, then considering why nobody has anywhere near that amount today. [1, 2]
Key Points from Seykota's Thought Experiment
The Compounding Paradox: Over roughly 2,026 years, a single cent ($0.01) compounded annually at 3% grows to approximately $1.02 × 10²⁴ (over a septillion dollars).
Why Nobody Has It: In real-world history, uninterrupted compounding at that scale does not happen because wars, collapses, confiscation, and currency debasement interrupt wealth preservation. [1]
Gold and Debasement: Seykota noted that inflation sweeps away old orders, currencies get debased, and gold gets dug up, refined, and buried again—trending toward centralized vaults rather than endless individual compounding. [1]
You can read more about his profile and quotes on 7 Circles or view a copy of Market Wizards via ValuePlays.
[quote]What is your long-term outlook for inflation, the dollar, and gold?
Inflation is part of the way societies sweep away the old order. All currencies eventually get debased—like it
or not. Compute one penny invested at the time of Christ, compounded at 3 percent per year. Then consider why nobody has anywhere near that amount these days.
Gold tends to be dug up, refined, and then buried again. The geographical entropy of all gold on the planet
seems to decrease over time. A lot has been collected in vaults. I project the trend as one toward a central world gold stash.[/quote]
Interview with Ed Seykota in
THE MARKET WIZARDS
CONVERSATIONS WITH AMERICA'S TOP TRADERS
JACK D. SCHWAGER
[quote]What was your worst year? What went wrong?
One of my worst years was 1980. The bull markets had ended, but I kept trying to hold on and buy back in at
lower prices. The markets just kept on breaking. I had never seen a major bear market before, so I was all set up for an important educational experience.[/quote]
[quote=Higgenbotham post_id=95833 time=1793994264 user_id=100]
[quote=Higgenbotham post_id=95832 time=1793990170 user_id=100]
There will be a new set of winners who can be identified later. Kind of like how Joe Granville was the man in the 1970s.[/quote]
I don't think the world any longer correctly understands Joe Granville. This article perhaps comes the closest but it's still off the mark.
[quote]What Happened: On this day in 1981, Joe Granville warned his newsletter readers to "Sell everything!"
Where The Market Was: The Dow closed at 1,004.69 and the S&P 500 traded at 138.12.
Granville's Bold Prediction: On Jan. 6, 1981, in his weekly newsletter, Granville warned investors that a stock market crash was on the horizon and they should dump all their stocks. The following day, the Dow tanked 4.2% on record trading volume of 92.9 million shares, making Granville look like a genius.
A year after Granville's call, the Dow was still down 14%, and Granville had become famous for calling the drop. At the time, Granville has 11,000 newsletter subscribers paying $250 per year for his insight. Others paid $500 for urgent phone alerts.
Granville's followers praised him for his 1981 call, his prediction of the bear market in the late 1970s and his bearish call ahead of the bursting of the dot-com bubble in 2000. Critics point out that he completely missed the bull market that started in 1982.
While Granville gained notoriety for his 1981 call, his overall performance was far from impressive. From 1980 through January 2005, Granville's stock picks for investors lost 0.5% on an annualized basis compared to an 11.9% average yearly gain from the market as a whole.[/quote]
https://finance.yahoo.com/news/day-market-history-granville-warns-151500153.html
As other articles incorrectly state, Joe Granville was not primarily a showman. Granville had a good understanding of markets. He was primarily a bearish stock market prognosticator who made a number of correct stock market calls as the bear market wound its way down to the 1982 low. As posted awhile back, the Buffett Indicator made its low of 0.32 in 1982. That's how he got his following of tens of thousands of subscribers, not because of his showmanship.
For the purposes of what is being discussed here, it doesn't matter that Joe Granville missed the bull market post 1982 and lost his subscribers money after 1982. As long as there is no bull market coming for the next 20 years.
Whoever that person is (or persons are, hopefully) who is now bearish and can reasonably find the twists and turns to the bottom of the coming bear market is yet to be identified. Granville had a great run in the 70s, calling a number of turns. That seems to have been completely forgotten. That's why he was seemingly able to move markets.
If a bear market is starting someone with a similar talent will probably come to the fore. I will be on the lookout for such a person and will take their opinion into account. But as of yet there is no such identifiable person.[/quote]
I read the Seykota interview 32 years ago. It's much more meaningful today, particularly given the environment that I believe we are going into. Reading the entire Seykota interview in Market Wizards will give good insight into what I'm talking about here. For one:
[quote]
What is the most important advice you can give the average trader?
That he should find a superior trader to do his trading for him, and then go find something he really loves to
do.[/quote]
One thing to keep in mind is that Seykota built and used a trend following system at the time the US entered the maintenance phase of a declining civilization. His success appears to have been temporarily interrupted just at the time when Joe Granville was in his heyday.
From the Seykota interview:
[quote]What was your first trading-related job?
I landed my first job on Wall Street in the early 1970s..
[/quote]
[quote]
What is the performance track record?
I do not publicize my track record other than my "model account," which is an actual customer account that
started with $5,000 in 1972 and has made over $15 million.[/quote]
This is similar to how Warren Buffet got established at the time the last crisis ended and the US entered into a big growth phase and world domination, which was the perfect environment for his talent. I believe that if Buffet were coming of age today, he would die penniless.