Higgenbotham wrote:
> Another obvious question is where are we at compared to the first
> two bubbles. Probably in unprecedented territory. There is no
> comparison that can be made. This can be seen by the fact that
> there was a huge move down right from the top of this bubble
> whereas that did not happen from the tops of the previous two
> bubbles.
I believe that the current bubble is fundamentally different from the
earlier two bubbles. The earlier bubbles, as well as the 1929 bubble,
were entirely internal to the United States -- the 1920s Wall Street
bubble, the 1990s tech bubble, the 2000s real estate/credit bubble.
But today's bubble is largely exogenous. Yes there's a Wall Street
bubble, but this time Wall Street is heavily interlocked with stock
markets and financial centers around the world, and the Wall Street
bubble is smaller than all the other bubbles put together.
I understand that total debt in the United States is $60 trillion, of
which $18 trillion is federal government debt. I've also heard that
total debt in the world is $250 trillion. So, once again, the debt
exposure of the United States is big, but only a small fraction of the
world debt, in countries with whose economies are interlocked with
ours. That means that if almost anyone else sneezes, then we catch a
cold.
I've been trying to explore some of these concepts in the currency
area, when I've been writing about the devaluation of the Chinese
yuan, then the Afghanistan tenge, and then various African currencies.
These actions have all strengthened the US dollar, making the US goods
and services less competitive in the world.
This week there's been some big news that China is selling off over
$100 billion of US Treasuries. This will strengthen the American
dollar even more, possibly significantly. This is possibly the best
explanation for the huge move down right that you mention. This would
be an example of how the current situation is significantly different
from previous ones, because today we're reacting to exogenous events,
not internal ones as in the past.