Generational Dynamics World View News

Discussion of Web Log and Analysis topics from the Generational Dynamics web site.
Navigator
Posts: 1116
Joined: Wed Feb 06, 2019 2:15 pm

Re: Generational Dynamics World View News

Post by Navigator »

I guess I should start posting about the Iran mess. There is just so much there to unpack, it is daunting to even start.

So I will just start with the beginning. Bombing alone NEVER fixes anything permanently. I am sure that Trump and Hegseth were told by their personally picked Chairman of the Chiefs of Staff, an Air Force General ("Raisin" Caine) that bombing could do the trick alone. The Air Force (and its predecessor the Army Air Force, heck, all major Air Forces) have been peddling this since the 1920's. It comes from an Italian Air Force general named Douhet. It didn't work in WW2, it didn't work in Vietnam, it was insufficient in Iraq (think Shock and Awe), and its insufficient now.

Anyhow, others should have cautioned Trump (they probably did, Vance probably amongst them) that ground troops would eventually be needed.

That is where things stood even a few months ago. It is impossible to secure the Straits of Hormuz without taking some significant real estate. This includes the minor islands between Iran and the Arabian coast, the much more significant island of Qeshm, and probably coastal areas around the port of Bandar Abbas.

I think that the other miscalculation was that the Iranian people were going to rise up and overthrow the fundamentalist regime. This was also beyond wishful thinking. Tiananmen Square proved pretty conclusively (in modern times) that if the people in power are willing to machine gun their own population, no revolt is going to happen. And the IRGC is more than willing to kill millions of fellow Iranians if that is what it takes for them to stay in power.

The Iranians as a whole are going to experience a collapse of their civilian economy, but even that isn't going to force the IRGC from power. The Iranian people are basically enslaved.

Now that the election is over, Trump may indeed commit ground troops. Iran may help him by doing something stupid, like a terror attack on US soil.
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests