So, last night I decided to spend a few hours looking into the concept of the "American Nations."
For those who are unaware of this concept, in 2011 Colin Woodard released a book titled
American Nations. This book proposes that the United States can be divided into several different "nations" with entirely different cultures. The nature of these cultures were largely determined by the cultures of the original settlers.
Below is a colorized version of the map that Woodard created for his book, courtesy of Business Insider.
Notice that the divisions are made at the county level. I decided to make my own version of that map, but with the divisions at the state level. I did this because I believe that if America were ever to break up, the states likely would align according to the cultures mentioned in Woodard's book. Note that I did only the contiguous 48 states.
The alignments are determined by which counties each state's population lives in. Based on my research, 43 of the contiguous 48 states have an absolute majority of their populations living in counties that are within a single cultural zones. The other 5 are what I refer to as "cleft states."
The alignments are as follows:
Deep South: Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Mississippi, and South Carolina
El Norte: Arizona and California
Far West: Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming
Greater Appalachia: Arkansas, Indiana, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Tennessee, and West Virginia
Left Coast: Oregon and Washington
Midlands: Delaware, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Missouri, Nebraska, and Pennsylvania
New France: Louisiana
New Netherland: New Jersey and New York
Tidewater: Virginia
Yankeedom: Connecticut, Illinois, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Wisconsin
Cleft States: North Carolina*, North Dakota**, Ohio***, South Dakota**, and Texas****
*The plurality of North Carolina's population belongs to Greater Appalachia, but there are also significant minorities who belong to the Deep South or Tidewater.
**The plurality of the population in both Dakotas belongs to Yankeedom, but there are also significant minorities who belong to the Far West or the Midlands.
***The plurality Ohio's population belongs to Greater Appalachia, but there are also significant minorities who belong to the Midlands and Yankeedom.
****The plurality of Texas' population belongs to Greater Appalachia, but there are also significant minorities who belong to the Deep South, El Norte, and the Midlands.