OLD1953 wrote:
My point about growth in US manufacturing seems to be misunderstood, there was a net loss of 6 million jobs in that sector over the ten years from 2000 to 2010. Even a reduction of losses would be good news, that it appears to have bottomed out and actually seeing growth in the sector is excellent news indeed. Curves plunge to a nadir, then they TURN AROUND and start back up. We appear to have passed the worst for the manufacturing sector in the US. I doubt manufacturing will somehow "save us" and I doubt anything can or will, but actual good news about any part of the economy is a rare thing these days, so cherish it.
The above information would be significant if it were a full picture of what has been happening over that past 40 years, the reasons it has been happening, and there was evidence that a true NADIR had been reached and a strong rebound was truly in progress.
For example:
OLD1953 wrote:
My point about growth in US manufacturing seems to be misunderstood, there was a net loss of 6 million jobs in that sector over the ten years from 2000 to 2010.
The substantial loss of manufacturing jobs began in the 1970s and has continued in every decade since then. There are many fundamental reasons for these huge job losses , and if those fundamental reasons had been reversed, that would indeed be important new. But the opposite is true.
Huge manufacturing wage differentials remain between the U.S. and China, India and other asian manufacturing giants still exist. Health care costs paid by manufacturing companies in the U.S. remains a huge burden for U.S. manufacturing and it does not hinder the large manufacturing companies in Asia. Obama care fails to fix that problem and instead makes it worse. Mining, a key United States economic sector needed to support manufacturing, has also left the United States over that same 40 year period. High U.S. taxes on manufacturing corporations and double taxation on manufacturing dividends in the United States has pushed, and continues to push, U.S. manufacturing jobs out of the United States. Strict, and unnecessarily burdensome to comply with, Environmental laws in the United States make both mining and manufacturing in the United States vastly more expensive in the United States than many other locations these activities can be done.
These underlying reasons manufacturing jobs left have not reversed in the last year, or last 2 years, or last 3 years, or the last decade.
OLD1953 wrote:Even a reduction of losses would be good news, that it appears to have bottomed out and actually seeing growth in the sector is excellent news indeed. Curves plunge to a nadir, then they TURN AROUND and start back up. We appear to have passed the worst for the manufacturing sector in the US.
The number of manufacturing jobs have declined substantially for every decade, for the past four decades. There is no solid evidence we have reached the true NADIR nor is there any evidence at all that the up side of a V shaped up curve has been reached. Indeed the evidence than any up curve at all has been reached, regardless how short and weak it is, is also being put in question by the constant revision of the few very slightly positive months that appeared to exist before the revisions.
OLD1953 wrote:
actual good news about any part of the economy is a rare thing these days, so cherish it.
The number of jobs as a percentage of working age people has been declining for at least four years now. Nothing in the manufacturing jobs numbers, which have, after decades of manufacturing jobs moving out of the United States, become an almost insignificant portion of the United States economy, has changed that.
Even if one believes the reported declining estimates of illegal immigration by the Obama administration the official records of births indicate the United States is unable to even begin a recovery capable of generating enough jobs for the increase in population. People getting out of college and people in their fifties are dropping out of the work force due to the current economy. As a result both the absolute number of people working and the official unemployment rate are dropping at the same time for the first time in history.
There is nothing to celebrate in the manufacturing jobs number, or any other numbers related to so-called "job increases" in this economy.